Am I Required to Pay This Bill?
Original Medicare is different from any other health insurance, including MA (Medicare Advantage), in that you are required to be told IN ADVANCE that there is a possibility Medicare may not pay for your test or procedure.
If the patient prepays the bill (before the claim is filed and adjudicated) they will most likely pay the "full retail" cost of the test or procedure. This will almost assuredly be higher than the repriced Medicare amount if the claim is approved.
Patients with MA don't have a choice, at least where a copay is required and prior authorization is not in play.
The ABN (Advance Beneficiary Notification) is unique to OM. I have never encountered anything like that with other types of health insurance. Basically, if Medicare does not approve the
claim, the patient is not obligated to pay the bill.
Period!
As for providers that require prepay for OM patients, my guess is they tell the patient to pay knowing many will
comply.
I have used the same dermatologist for 10 years. Early on they would check my deductible status and ask (tell, actually) to pay $X before leaving. I politely declined, reminding them that Medicare does not require prepayment before the claim is submitted and adjudicated.
I always pay bills AFTER they are submitted to Medicare and I tell my clients to do the same.
Your Protections
If you have Original Medicare, your doctor, other health care provider, or supplier may give you a
written notice if they think Medicare won’t pay for the items or services you’ll get. This notice is called an “Advance Beneficiary Notice of Non-coverage,” or ABN. The ABN lists the items or services that your doctor or health care provider expects Medicare will not pay for, along with an estimate of the costs for the items and services and the reasons why Medicare may not pay.
What can I do if I get this notice?
On the ABN, you’ll be asked to choose an option box and sign the notice to say that you read and understood it. You must choose one of these options:
Option 1: You want items or services that Medicare may not pay for. Your provider or supplier may ask you to pay for these items or services now, but you also want your provider or supplier to submit a claim to Medicare.
If Medicare denies payment: You’re responsible for paying. However, since a claim was submitted, you
can appeal to Medicare.
If Medicare does pay: Your provider or supplier will refund any payments you made (not including your copayments or deductibles).
Option 2: You want
items or services that Medicare may not pay for, but you don’t want your provider or supplier to submit a claim to Medicare. You may be asked to pay for the items or services now. Because you asked your provider or supplier not to submit a claim to Medicare, you can’t file an appeal.
Option 3: You don’t want the items or
services that Medicare may not pay for, and you aren’t responsible for any payments. A claim isn’t submitted to Medicare, and you can’t file an appeal.
The ABN is designed to protect you from having to pay for claims that are not APPROVED BY MEDICARE.
https://www.medicare.gov/basics/your-medicare-rights/your-protections
Read carefully . . .